Rochester, New York, is a city that any food lover would enjoy. With a variety of eateries offering everything from classic diner fare to unique local specialties, there’s something for everyone. As a local, I’ve explored many of these spots and can confidently guide you to some of the best places to eat in the city. While this list isn’t exhaustive, it’s a great starting point for anyone looking to experience the culinary delights that Rochester has to offer. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a sweet treat, or a gourmet dinner, you’ll find it here.
Key Takeaways
- Highland Park Diner offers a classic 1940s diner experience with large portions and a nostalgic atmosphere.
- Balsam Bagels is a must-visit for bagel lovers, offering both New York and Montreal style bagels.
- Village Bakery provides a quick and delicious breakfast option with multiple locations on the East side.
- Abbott’s Frozen Custard is the go-to spot for a sweet treat, with nearly 100 years of history in Rochester.
- Nick Tahou Hots is the place to try Rochester’s famous Garbage Plate, a unique and hearty local dish.
1. Highland Park Diner
Step into a piece of history at Highland Park Diner, a retro-styled trailer that stands as one of Rochester’s architectural gems. This local favorite is known for its fluffy pancakes—the banana Nutella variety is a must-try—and bottomless coffee. The diner offers a classic 1940s boxcar experience with large portions and a nostalgic atmosphere.
Highlights
- Fluffy pancakes (try the banana Nutella)
- Bottomless coffee
- Classic 1940s boxcar diner experience
- Large portions
- Giant milkshakes
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Highland Park Diner is a spot you shouldn’t miss. Enjoy a hearty breakfast or lunch served all day in a setting that takes you back in time.
2. Balsam Bagels
Balsam Bagels is a must-visit for any bagel lover in Rochester. This spot is known for its delicious New York and Montreal style bagels, making it a local favorite. Expect a line on weekend mornings, but the wait is worth it. They offer a wide variety of locally made cream cheeses that perfectly complement their bagels. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast or picking up a dozen for the office, Balsam Bagels won’t disappoint.
3. Village Bakery
Nestled in the heart of Rochester, Village Bakery is a must-visit for anyone who loves freshly baked goods. This charming spot offers a wide variety of pastries, bread, and other baked delights that are sure to satisfy your cravings. Their croissants are legendary, often described as the best in town. Whether you’re in the mood for a sweet treat or a savory snack, Village Bakery has something for everyone.
One of the highlights of Village Bakery is their commitment to using local ingredients. This not only supports local farmers but also ensures that everything is as fresh as possible. The bakery’s cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a relaxing breakfast or a casual lunch.
If you’re a fan of brunch, you’ll be pleased to know that Village Bakery offers an excellent brunch menu. From classic eggs Benedict to unique dishes like avocado toast with a twist, there’s something to please every palate. Don’t forget to try their freshly squeezed orange juice, which pairs perfectly with any meal.
For a memorable dining experience, Village Bakery is a top choice in Rochester. The combination of delicious food, friendly service, and a welcoming environment makes it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
4. Abbott’s Frozen Custard
Abbott’s Frozen Custard is a beloved spot in Rochester, known for its rich and creamy frozen custard. Even during the harshest winter days, the Lake Avenue location remains open, serving up delicious treats. Their custard is made fresh daily, ensuring a delightful experience every time.
When you visit, don’t miss out on their signature Turtle, which features layers of Abbott’s frozen custard, Spanish peanuts, and fudge, all frozen on a stick and dipped in dark chocolate. It’s a must-try!
For nearly 100 years, Abbott’s has been a go-to destination for a sweet treat in Rochester. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, this spot is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
5. Nick Tahou Hots
Nick Tahou Hots is a must-visit when you’re in Rochester. Nick Tahou serves up the best and most legendary plates in Rochester. The restaurant is famous for its iconic Garbage Plate, a dish that has become a local legend. The Garbage Plate includes your choice of protein, such as cheeseburger, hamburger, or Italian sausages, served on a bed of home fries, french fries, baked beans, or macaroni salad. It’s then topped with a spicy meat sauce, with optional mustard and onions.
The Garbage Plate is a unique culinary experience that you won’t find anywhere else. Many other places have tried to replicate it, but Nick Tahou Hots is the original spot. If you’re in Rochester, do not miss out on this legendary dish!
6. The Cub Room
The Cub Room is a must-visit spot in Rochester for those who appreciate a blend of history and modern dining. Located in a former factory, this restaurant offers a unique ambiance with its exposed brick walls and industrial-chic decor. The atmosphere is both cozy and sophisticated, making it perfect for a romantic dinner or a night out with friends.
The menu at The Cub Room is a delightful mix of American cuisine with a contemporary twist. You can start your meal with appetizers like crispy calamari or truffle fries. For the main course, options range from succulent steaks to mouth-watering seafood dishes. Don’t forget to save room for dessert; their chocolate lava cake is a crowd favorite.
The Cub Room also boasts an impressive drink menu. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic cocktail or something more adventurous, their skilled bartenders have you covered. The wine list is extensive, featuring selections from around the world.
The Cub Room is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience. From the moment you walk in, you’re treated to top-notch service and a memorable dining experience.
7. REDD Rochester
Located in the heart of downtown, REDD Rochester is a must-visit for food enthusiasts. The restaurant is helmed by a Michelin-starred chef who brings a touch of California wine country to the menu. The sophisticated crowd enjoys a variety of dishes that are both innovative and delicious. The ambiance is chic, making it perfect for a special night out.
- Cuisine: California wine country-inspired
- Chef: Michelin-starred
- Location: Downtown Rochester
For those looking to explore Rochester’s vibrant culinary scene, REDD is a top choice. The combination of fine dining and a stylish setting makes it a standout.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, make sure to add REDD Rochester to your list of dining destinations. The experience is sure to be memorable.
8. The Revelry
The Revelry, located at 1290 University Ave, is a gem in Rochester’s dining scene. Housed in a former industrial building, it offers a unique blend of Southern charm and modern flair. Owner Josh Miles has been delighting the Finger Lakes region with flavors from the mountains and Lowcountry for a decade. The menu features classic dishes from all over the country, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
If you’re a fan of hearty, meatless meals, the smoked mushrooms are a must-try. And while the food is fantastic, the cocktails truly steal the show. For a tropical twist, try the Space Thyme. Whether you’re there for the food or the drinks, The Revelry promises a memorable experience.
The Revelry is a perfect spot for those looking to explore Albany’s vibrant shopping scene, featuring artisanal jewelry, gourmet food, and unique local shops. Discover local food markets brimming with fresh produce and specialty stores offering rare ingredients. Whether indulging in high-quality gourmet products or finding hidden treasures, Albany provides a delightful shopping experience for every taste.
9. Strangebird
Strangebird Brewing is a must-visit spot in Rochester, especially if you love craft beer. Open since 2021, this brewery quickly earned the title of 2022 New York State Craft Brewery of the Year. Their award-winning beers are a big draw, but don’t overlook the food menu. The star here is the pizza, baked in large brick ovens that give it an irresistible Neapolitan-style crust. If you’re not in the mood for pizza, they also offer a few tasty sandwiches. Good food and good beer—what more could you ask for?
10. The Owl House
Nestled in the heart of Rochester, The Owl House is a must-visit for food lovers. This cozy spot offers a unique menu that caters to various dietary preferences, including vegan and gluten-free options. Their creative dishes are crafted with locally sourced ingredients, ensuring fresh and flavorful meals every time.
The Owl House is known for its warm and inviting atmosphere, making it a perfect place for a casual meal or a special occasion. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, always ready to recommend the best dishes and drinks to suit your taste.
If you’re a fan of craft beers, you’ll be delighted by their extensive selection of local brews. Pair your meal with one of their carefully curated beers for a complete dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, The Owl House promises a memorable culinary adventure.
Conclusion
Rochester’s food scene is a treasure trove for any foodie. From classic diners and cozy cafes to trendy new spots and diverse ethnic eateries, there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, exploring these culinary delights is a must. So, grab a friend, pick a place from our guide, and enjoy the flavors of Rochester. Happy eating!
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of food does Highland Park Diner serve?
Highland Park Diner offers classic diner fare, including breakfast and lunch all day. Expect large portions, giant milkshakes, and a nostalgic atmosphere.
Are there any vegan or vegetarian options in Rochester?
Yes, Rochester has several vegan and vegetarian-friendly restaurants, including The Owl House, Red Fern, and Natural Oasis.
What makes Balsam Bagels special?
Balsam Bagels is known for its authentic New York and Montreal-style bagels and a wide selection of locally made cream cheese. It’s a popular spot, especially on weekends.
Where can I get dessert in Rochester?
Abbott’s Frozen Custard is a must-visit for dessert lovers. They offer a variety of frozen custards, including their famous Turtle.
What is a Garbage Plate and where can I try it?
A Garbage Plate is a local specialty that includes a mix of meats, home fries, macaroni salad, and more. You can try it at Nick Tahou Hots, the place where it was invented.
Is there a good place for brunch in Rochester?
The Cub Room is a great spot for brunch, offering a variety of delicious dishes in a cozy atmosphere.
Where can I find a good bakery in Rochester?
Village Bakery is a fantastic choice for fresh pastries, bread, and other baked goods. They have multiple locations on the East side of Rochester.
What are some trendy restaurants in Rochester?
The Revelry and REDD Rochester are popular trendy spots known for their innovative dishes and vibrant atmospheres.
Recent Posts
Ann Arbor is a city rich in history and culture, offering a variety of museums and historic sites that cater to all interests. From interactive science exhibits to ancient artifacts, there's...
Ann Arbor is a fantastic place to spend an evening, with plenty to see and do. Whether you love live music, dancing, or simply enjoying a good meal, this city has something special for you. Let's...