The Thrift Shopper’s Guide to NYC: Best Places for Vintage and Bargains

Thrifting in New York City is an adventure filled with surprises. From stylish clothes to unique furniture, every visit to these thrift stores can lead you to unexpected treasures. You might find a vintage jacket, a rare book, or even a cool piece of art. The best part? You’re not just shopping; you’re giving a second life to items that someone else no longer wants. Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or a newbie, this guide will help you navigate the best spots in the city to find amazing deals and vintage gems.

Key Takeaways

• NYC thrift stores offer a wide range of items from clothes to furniture.
• You can find unique and stylish pieces that tell a story.
• Shopping secondhand helps reduce waste and supports sustainability.
• Each store has its own vibe, so explore different neighborhoods.
• Thrifting can be a fun way to refresh your wardrobe without breaking the bank.

1. 2ND STREET

2ND STREET is a fantastic spot for thrift shoppers in NYC, especially if you’re looking for a mix of affordable and stylish finds. This store offers a great selection of both high-street brands and unique designer pieces. Located at 142 W 26th St in Chelsea, it’s a must-visit for anyone wanting to explore the world of secondhand fashion.

What to Expect

• A wide range of clothing from popular fast fashion brands.
• A small but curated section of designer items at the front.
• A friendly atmosphere that makes shopping enjoyable.

Why Visit?

• Budget-friendly prices compared to other thrift stores in the area.
• The chance to discover hidden gems among the racks.
• A vibrant shopping experience in a lively neighborhood.

"Thrift shopping is not just about saving money; it’s about finding unique pieces that tell a story."

Whether you’re a seasoned thrift shopper or just starting out, 2ND STREET is a great place to find your next favorite outfit!

2. BEACON’S CLOSET

Located in the heart of Greenwich Village, Beacon’s Closet is a must-visit for anyone looking to score some stylish secondhand finds. This store is where many trendy New Yorkers drop off their barely-worn clothes, making it a treasure trove for shoppers. You can discover everything from never-worn sneakers to chic handbags and cozy coats to keep you warm during the chilly months.

Each Beacon’s Closet location has its own unique vibe, reflecting the neighborhood it’s in. So, whether you choose to visit the Union Square or Bushwick location, you’re in for a delightful shopping experience.

What to Expect

• Trendy Items: Expect to find a mix of designer and vintage clothing.
• Affordable Prices: Many items are priced lower than retail, making it easy to find a bargain.
• Frequent Inventory Changes: The stock is constantly updated, so there’s always something new to discover.

Tips for Shopping

1. Visit Often: The inventory changes frequently, so check back regularly.
2. Try Everything On: Sizes can vary, so always try before you buy.
3. Look for Quality: Check for any defects or stains before making a purchase.

Shopping at Beacon’s Closet is not just about finding great deals; it’s about the thrill of the hunt and the joy of discovering unique pieces that tell a story.

With its cool atmosphere and fantastic selection, Beacon’s Closet is a top spot for thrift shoppers in NYC!

3. BUFFALO EXCHANGE

Buffalo Exchange is a must-visit for thrift lovers in NYC. Located at 208 E 6th St, this consignment store is known for its eclectic mix of vintage and designer items. You can find everything from vintage jeans to trendy jackets and unique accessories. The atmosphere is lively, and the store is often bustling with shoppers looking for their next great find.

Here’s what you can expect when you visit Buffalo Exchange:

• Wide Selection: The store is packed with a variety of clothing, shoes, and accessories.
• Affordable Prices: Items are priced much lower than retail, making it a great spot for bargains.
• Sustainable Shopping: By buying second-hand, you’re helping the environment and supporting a circular economy.

Buffalo Exchange is not just a store; it’s an experience where you can discover hidden gems and unique pieces that tell a story.

If you’re in the East Village, don’t miss out on this treasure trove of fashion!

4. L TRAIN VINTAGE

L Train Vintage is a must-visit for anyone looking to score some stylish finds in NYC. This store is a favorite among locals and newcomers alike! Located in the East Village, it’s known for its wide selection of vintage clothing that caters to all tastes.

What to Expect

• Diverse Selection: From classic Levi’s jeans to retro windbreakers, you’ll find a variety of styles.
• Affordable Prices: Most items are priced reasonably, making it easy to shop without breaking the bank.
• Frequent Restocks: The inventory changes often, so there’s always something new to discover.

Tips for Shopping

1. Visit Often: Since the stock is updated regularly, frequent visits can lead to great finds.
2. Check the Racks: Don’t hesitate to dig through the racks; treasures are often hidden among the less eye-catching pieces.
3. Try Everything On: Sizes can vary, so trying on clothes is essential to ensure a good fit.

L Train Vintage is not just a store; it’s a treasure hunt waiting to happen! Whether you’re looking for a unique outfit or just browsing, you’re sure to leave with something special.

5. URBAN JUNGLE

Urban Jungle is a true treasure trove for thrift shoppers. This store is packed with racks of clothing that showcase the unique styles of NYC over the years. Located in Bushwick, right next to L Train Vintage, it’s the perfect spot to spend a day exploring vintage finds.

What to Expect

• A wide variety of clothing from different eras
• Affordable prices that won’t break the bank
• A fun atmosphere that makes shopping enjoyable

Tips for Shopping at Urban Jungle

1. Visit often: The inventory changes frequently, so you might find something new each time.
2. Be patient: Sometimes, you have to dig a little to find the best pieces.
3. Bring a friend: Shopping is always more fun with someone to share the experience.

Urban Jungle is not just a store; it’s an adventure waiting to happen for anyone who loves vintage fashion.

6. CROSSROADS TRADING COMPANY

Crossroads Trading Company is a fantastic spot for thrift shopping in NYC. This store is known for its well-organized selection of high-street brands. Located at 47 W 13th St, it’s a place where you can find some real hidden gems.

What to Expect

• Curated Selection: The items are sorted by color and style, making it easy to browse.
• Affordable Prices: You can score designer pieces at a fraction of the original price. For example, I once found a Dolce & Gabbana jeans skirt for just $30!
• Friendly Staff: The service is attentive, especially near the dressing rooms, ensuring a pleasant shopping experience.

Why Visit?

• Great Deals: Many shoppers leave with high-quality items for much less than retail prices.
• Unique Finds: You never know what you might discover, from vintage dresses to trendy accessories.

Crossroads Trading is not just about saving money; it’s about finding unique pieces that tell a story.

If you’re in the area, make sure to stop by and see what treasures await you!

7. HOUSING WORKS

Housing Works is a fantastic place to find unique items while supporting a great cause. This charity thrift store chain has multiple locations across NYC, making it easy to pop in and browse. You can discover everything from clothing to home goods, all at reasonable prices.

Why Shop Here?

• Quality Stock: While prices may not be the absolute lowest, the quality of items is often top-notch.
• Designer Finds: You might even stumble upon some designer pieces that are usually out of your budget.
• Support a Cause: Your purchases help fund programs that assist low-income New Yorkers and fight homelessness.

Locations

Housing Works has several locations throughout Manhattan and Brooklyn. Here’s a quick look:

Shopping at Housing Works not only helps you find great deals but also contributes to meaningful change in the community.

So, if you’re on the hunt for vintage treasures or just want to refresh your wardrobe, make sure to check out Housing Works!

8. MOTHER OF JUNK

Located in the heart of Williamsburg, Mother of Junk is a treasure trove for vintage lovers. This unique shop spans over 5,000 square feet, offering a wide range of items from clothing to furniture. You can find everything from affordable furniture to quirky knick-knacks here!

What to Expect

• Diverse Selection: The store features vintage clothing, art, books, and even vinyl records.
• Affordable Prices: Most items are reasonably priced, making it a great spot for budget shoppers.
• Unique Finds: You never know what you might discover, from retro dresses to unique home decor.

Highlights

• Vinyl Records: A great collection for music lovers.
• Artwork: Perfect for those looking to spruce up their walls.

At Mother of Junk, every visit feels like a new adventure, as you sift through a delightful mix of old and new treasures waiting to be found!

9. DOBBIN STREET VINTAGE CO-OP

If you find yourself wandering through Greenpoint, make sure to stop by Dobbin Street Vintage Co-Op. This charming co-op is a treasure trove of second-hand finds, offering a delightful mix of clothing, accessories, and even furniture. You can easily spend hours browsing through their eclectic collection, which includes everything from stylish outfits to unique home decor.

What to Expect

• Diverse Selection: The co-op features a wide range of items, ensuring that there’s something for everyone.
• Affordable Prices: You’ll be surprised at how budget-friendly many of the items are, making it easy to snag a great deal.
• Friendly Atmosphere: The staff is welcoming and always ready to help you find that perfect piece.

Location

Dobbin Street Vintage Co-Op is located at 39 Norman Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222. It’s a perfect stop after enjoying a delicious brunch at nearby spots like Rule of Thirds or Eavesdrop.

At Dobbin Street, you’re bound to leave with something special, whether it’s a coffee table book or even a new coffee table!

10. VINTAGE THRIFT SHOP

Located in the heart of Gramercy, the Vintage Thrift Shop is a treasure trove for anyone who loves unique finds. This shop offers a fantastic mix of designer and non-vintage clothing, along with one-of-a-kind housewares and accessories. You might stumble upon vintage Yves Saint Laurent blouses or classic Salvatore Ferragamo pumps, making every visit an exciting adventure.

What to Expect

• Diverse Selection: From clothing to shoes and home decor, there’s something for everyone.
• Designer Finds: Look for items from top brands like Versace and Givenchy.
• Affordable Prices: Enjoy great deals while shopping for quality items.

At the shop’s second location, Vintage Thrift West, you can explore even more options, including men’s and women’s clothing displayed in a charming Tiffany jewelry case. The thrill of the hunt is real here, as you never know what hidden gems you might discover.

All proceeds from the Vintage Thrift Shop go to the United Jewish Council of the East Side, helping to support the local community.

Whether you’re a seasoned thrift shopper or just starting out, the Vintage Thrift Shop is a must-visit for anyone looking to score some amazing deals in NYC!

11. YESTERDAY’S NEWS

Yesterday’s News is a hidden gem located at 428 Court Street, Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn. This shop is a treasure trove of unique items, including vintage furniture, clothing, and collectibles. You can find everything from quirky tchotchkes to rare subway ads that take you back in time. It’s a must-visit for anyone who loves thrifting!

What to Expect

• A wide range of 20th-century antiques
• Vintage clothing for both men and women
• Unique collectibles that tell a story

Getting There

To reach Yesterday’s News, take the F or G train to Carroll Street. It’s just a short walk of two blocks from the station!

Thrifting is not just about finding items; it’s about the adventure of the hunt and the stories behind each piece.

12. NOMAD VINTAGE

NOMAD VINTAGE is a charming little boutique located at 208 E 6th St. This shop is a hidden gem for anyone who loves pre-loved and vintage fashion. Although it’s smaller than many chain stores, it offers a calming shopping experience, which is a nice change from the often overwhelming thrift scene in NYC.

The selection here is handpicked, featuring quality items from top designers alongside more affordable vintage pieces. You might find unique items like wool checkered trousers or a stunning vintage 70’s Comme des Garçons top.

Why Visit NOMAD VINTAGE?

• Unique Selection: Handpicked items from various designers.
• Charming Atmosphere: A cozy space that feels welcoming.
• Affordable Finds: Great vintage pieces at accessible prices.

If you’re looking for a delightful shopping experience, NOMAD VINTAGE is a must-visit!

13. STOCK VINTAGE

Located at 143 East 13th Street, New York, NY 10003, Stock Vintage is a treasure trove for those who love vintage menswear. This shop specializes in antique clothing and accessories from the early 1900s to the 1970s. Whether you’re searching for a classic suit or unique accessories, you’re likely to find something special here.

What to Expect:

• A carefully curated selection of vintage menswear.
• Items ranging from the early 1900s to the 1970s.
• A friendly atmosphere where you can take your time browsing.

Why Visit?

• Quality: Each piece is handpicked for its quality and style.
• Variety: From casual wear to formal attire, there’s something for everyone.
• Unique Finds: You never know what hidden gems you might discover!

Visiting Stock Vintage is like stepping back in time, where every item has a story to tell.

14. PAULA RUBENSTEIN

Paula Rubenstein is a hidden gem for vintage lovers in NYC. This shop is known for its unique collection of clothing and accessories that tell a story. Located in the heart of the city, it offers a cozy atmosphere where you can spend hours browsing through racks of carefully curated items.

What to Expect

• A wide range of vintage clothing from different eras.
• Accessories that add a special touch to any outfit.
• Friendly staff who are always ready to help you find the perfect piece.

Tips for Shopping

1. Visit during weekdays for a quieter experience.
2. Check back often, as new items arrive regularly.
3. Don’t hesitate to ask about the history of a piece; the staff loves to share stories.

Shopping at Paula Rubenstein is not just about finding clothes; it’s about discovering treasures that connect you to the past.

15. 9TH ST. VINTAGE

Located in the heart of New York’s East Village, 9th St. Vintage is a must-visit for anyone who loves vintage women’s clothing. This charming boutique offers a carefully curated selection of unique pieces that reflect the styles of past decades. Whether you’re searching for a classic dress or trendy accessories, you’re likely to find something special here.

What to Expect

• Diverse Selection: From 60s mod dresses to 90s grunge, the variety is impressive.
• Affordable Prices: You can snag great deals without breaking the bank.
• Friendly Staff: The shopkeepers are always ready to help you find the perfect item.

Location

• Address: 346 East 9th Street, New York, NY 10003, USA

Why Shop Here?

Shopping at 9th St. Vintage not only allows you to find unique clothing but also supports local businesses. Explore the vibrant shopping scene and discover treasures that tell a story.

Shopping here is not just about finding clothes; it’s about embracing a lifestyle that values sustainability and creativity.

So, if you’re in the area, make sure to stop by and see what hidden gems await you!

16. MADAME MATOVU

Madame Matovu is a hidden gem in the West Village, perfect for those who love vintage fashion. This charming shop offers a delightful selection of glamorous women’s clothing and accessories. You can also find unique art books and home decor pieces that add a special touch to your space.

What to Expect

• Vintage Clothing: A variety of styles from different eras.
• Accessories: Jewelry and bags that complete your look.
• Art Books: Beautifully curated selections for art lovers.
• Home Decor: Unique items to enhance your living space.

Location

• Address: 240 West 10th Street, West Village, New York, NY 10014, USA

If you’re on the hunt for something special, Madame Matovu is a must-visit. The shop’s atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a great place to spend an afternoon browsing through its treasures.

"Shopping here feels like a treasure hunt, where every corner reveals something unique!"

Whether you’re looking for a standout outfit or a special gift, this shop is sure to impress. Don’t miss out on the chance to discover your next favorite piece!

17. DESERT VINTAGE

Desert Vintage is a hidden gem located at 34 Orchard Street, New York, NY 10002. This shop specializes in a carefully curated selection of vintage and antique clothing and accessories, making it a must-visit for anyone who loves unique fashion.

What to Expect

• A wide range of womenswear options, from dresses to accessories.
• Items that reflect quality and style, perfect for those looking to stand out.
• A cozy atmosphere that makes shopping a delightful experience.

At Desert Vintage, you can find pieces that tell a story and add character to your wardrobe.

Whether you’re hunting for a vintage dress for a special occasion or just browsing for fun, Desert Vintage offers something for everyone. Don’t miss out on this charming spot during your thrift shopping adventure in NYC!

18. COUNTRY OF

Located in the heart of the Lower East Side, Country Of is a must-visit for vintage lovers. This shop specializes in USA, Japanese, and European-made vintage clothing, particularly from the vibrant 80s and 90s. Whether you’re hunting for unique pieces or just browsing, you’re sure to find something special here.

What to Expect:

• A wide selection of vintage clothing
• Focus on styles from the 80s and 90s
• Friendly and knowledgeable staff to help you find the perfect item

Tip: Don’t forget to check out their accessories to complete your look!

"Country Of is a treasure trove for anyone who loves vintage fashion. You never know what gems you might find!"

If you’re in the area, make sure to stop by and explore their collection. You might just discover your new favorite outfit!

19. HELLO BANANA

If you’re on the hunt for vintage women’s clothing, Hello Banana is a must-visit! Located at 156 1st Avenue in the East Village, this boutique specializes in fabulous 60s and 70s styles. You’ll find a carefully curated selection of clothing and accessories that will make you feel like you’ve stepped back in time.

What to Expect

• Unique Finds: Expect to discover one-of-a-kind pieces that stand out.
• Affordable Prices: Great quality without breaking the bank.
• Friendly Staff: The team is always ready to help you find the perfect outfit.

Why Visit?

Hello Banana is not just a store; it’s an experience! The vibrant atmosphere and eclectic collection make it a fun place to shop. Whether you’re looking for a vintage dress for a special occasion or just browsing for something unique, you won’t leave empty-handed.

"Shopping here feels like a treasure hunt, and you never know what amazing piece you might find!"

So, if you’re in NYC and love vintage fashion, make sure to stop by Hello Banana for a delightful shopping experience!

20. MERCER STREET BOOKS

Located at 69 Mercer Street, this charming shop is a hidden gem in the heart of Greenwich Village. Mercer Street Books is not just a bookstore; it’s also a record store that has been serving the community since 1990. Here, you can find a carefully curated selection of books and vinyl records that cater to various tastes.

What to Expect

• A cozy atmosphere perfect for browsing.
• A mix of new and used books, including rare finds.
• A collection of vinyl records that music lovers will appreciate.

Whether you’re looking for a good read or a classic album, Mercer Street Books has something for everyone. It’s a great spot to spend an afternoon, especially if you enjoy discovering unique items that tell a story.

This shop is a must-visit for anyone who loves books and music, making it a perfect stop on your thrift shopping adventure in NYC!

21. CITY FOUNDRY

City Foundry is a hidden gem located in Brooklyn, showcasing a unique collection of industrial and mid-century furniture. This antique shop is perfect for anyone looking to add a touch of vintage charm to their home. With a carefully curated selection of quality pieces, you’re sure to find something special.

What to Expect

• Antiques: A variety of antique items that tell a story.
• Furniture: Mid-century and industrial styles that fit any decor.
• Lighting: Unique lighting fixtures that brighten up any space.

Location

• Address: 33 35th Street, Industry City, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting out, City Foundry offers a delightful shopping experience.

Vintage shopping here is not just about finding items; it’s about discovering pieces that resonate with your personal style.

If you’re on the hunt for the 14 best places for vintage furniture in NYC, make sure to include City Foundry in your itinerary!

22. FRONT GENERAL STORE

Located in the heart of Dumbo, Brooklyn, Front General Store is a must-visit for anyone who loves a mix of new and vintage items. This charming emporium offers a delightful selection of clothing, jewelry, and home goods that cater to both men and women.

What to Expect

• A carefully curated collection of vintage and contemporary clothing.
• Unique homeware that adds character to any space.
• Accessories that range from stylish jewelry to practical items.

Location

• Address: 143 Front Street, Dumbo, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Whether you’re hunting for a standout outfit or a special gift, this store has something for everyone.

"Front General Store is not just a shop; it’s an experience where you can find treasures that tell a story."

With its friendly atmosphere and diverse offerings, it’s a perfect spot for thrift shoppers looking to uncover unique finds.

23. ARCADE

A Vintage Wonderland

ARCADE is a delightful spot located in Brooklyn, known for its rotating selection of vintage clothing, accessories, and jewelry. This shop features items from global vendors, making it a unique treasure trove for thrift shoppers.

What to Expect

When you step into ARCADE, you can expect:

• A wide variety of womenswear
• Unique accessories that stand out
• Beautiful jewelry pieces that add flair to any outfit

Why Visit?

ARCADE is perfect for anyone looking to find something special. Whether you’re hunting for a vintage dress or a unique accessory, this shop has something for everyone. Plus, the ever-changing inventory means you can visit often and always find something new!

"Shopping here feels like a treasure hunt, where every visit brings new surprises!"

Location

• Address: 51 35th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11232
• Hours: Check their website for current hours and special events.

In summary, ARCADE is a must-visit for vintage lovers and bargain hunters alike. Don’t miss out on the chance to explore this vibrant shop!

24. CHICKEE’S VINTAGE

Chickee’s Vintage is a charming little shop located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. This store is known for its carefully curated selection of vintage clothing and accessories. You can find everything from stylish Gucci loafers to classic Levi’s jeans and unique graphic tees.

Location

• Address: 135 Wythe Avenue, Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY 11249, USA

What to Expect

• A well-organized space that makes it easy to browse.
• A mix of high-end designer pieces and casual vintage wear.
• Friendly staff ready to help you find the perfect item.

Highlights

• Designer Finds: Look out for luxury brands like Gucci.
• Casual Classics: Levi’s jeans and vintage graphic tees are popular here.
• Men’s Section: There’s a separate store nearby just for menswear.

Chickee’s Vintage is a must-visit for anyone who loves vintage fashion. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the selection is top-notch!

25. EDITH MACHINIST

Edith Machinist is a hidden gem for those who love vintage fashion. This cozy shop is packed with unique finds that can make any outfit stand out. You’ll discover everything from retro dresses to quirky accessories. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot to spend an afternoon browsing.

What to Expect

• Diverse Selection: You can find clothing from various decades, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
• Affordable Prices: Most items are reasonably priced, allowing you to snag great deals without breaking the bank.
• Friendly Staff: The staff is knowledgeable and always ready to help you find that perfect piece.

Tips for Shopping at Edith Machinist

1. Visit Often: The inventory changes frequently, so regular visits can lead to new treasures.
2. Try Everything On: Sizes can vary, so it’s best to try items on to see how they fit.
3. Ask for Help: Don’t hesitate to ask staff for recommendations or assistance.

Shopping here feels like a treasure hunt, where every visit can lead to a delightful surprise!

Whether you’re a seasoned thrift shopper or just starting, Edith Machinist is a must-visit for anyone looking to add some vintage flair to their wardrobe.

Final Thoughts on Thrifting in NYC

Thrifting in New York City is like a treasure hunt where you never know what cool stuff you might find. From stylish clothes to unique furniture, each store has its own charm and surprises. Whether you’re looking for a vintage jacket or a funky piece of art, NYC’s thrift shops have something for everyone. Plus, shopping secondhand is a great way to save money and help the planet by giving items a new home. So grab your friends, hit the streets, and enjoy the thrill of finding your next favorite piece in the city that never sleeps!

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I expect to find in NYC thrift stores?

NYC thrift stores offer a wide variety of items, from clothes and shoes to furniture and unique collectibles. You might discover vintage clothing, designer pieces, or even quirky home decor.

Are the prices at thrift stores in NYC affordable?

Prices can vary, but many thrift stores offer great deals compared to regular retail prices. You can find items for just a few dollars, especially during sales.

How do I know if a thrift store is good?

Look for stores with a good reputation, positive reviews, and a wide selection of items. Visiting multiple stores can also help you find the best deals.

Can I sell my clothes at thrift stores?

Many thrift stores offer buy-sell-trade options, allowing you to sell your gently-used clothes in exchange for store credit or cash.

Is thrifting environmentally friendly?

Yes! Thrifting helps reduce waste by giving new life to pre-owned items, which is better for the planet compared to buying new.

What should I wear when thrift shopping?

Wear comfortable clothes and shoes since you might be walking around and trying on various items. It’s also helpful to wear layers.

How often do thrift stores restock their items?

Restocking varies by store, but many thrift shops receive new items daily or weekly. Visiting often can help you find fresh treasures.

Are thrift stores only for clothes?

Not at all! While many thrift stores focus on clothing, you can also find furniture, books, art, and a range of home goods.